The Cost Of Holding Back The Dark

Rather than religious dogmas, I really like the metaphor of light and dark, which is used many times in the bible. Light, we can all agree, helps us see, gives some clarity, and is generally good. We need sunlight to be healthy. Plants need sunlight to grow.

In a spiritual sense, the same metaphor is helpful: ‘Light’ helps us to flourish, and spiritual ‘darkness’ breeds destruction and hatred. I play with these ideas regularly in my artworks, particularly the lighbulb personified as a whimsical character which represents Jesus (as described in the bible as the ‘light of the world’).

‘The Cost Of Holding Back The Darkness’ 2025

Several influences sparked this:

-I made my husband watch True Detective (season 1) which has two of my favourite actors. It is a really powerful story. There’s a dialogue between Matthew McConaughey’s nihilistic, philosopical character (Rust) and Woody Harrelson’s character (Marty) right at the end (so stop reading; spoilers lol) in which they look up at the night sky and discuss light and dark (good in the world vs the evil they have just encountered through the season).

Here’s the dialogue:

Rust: “I tell you Marty I been up in that room looking out those windows every night here just thinking, it’s just one story. The oldest.”

Marty: “What’s that?”

Rust: “Light versus dark.”

Marty: “Well, I know we ain’t in Alaska, but it appears to me that the dark has a lot more territory.”

Rust: “Yeah, you’re right about that.”

Rust insists that Marty help him leave the hospital, and Marty agrees. As they head to the car, Rust makes one final point to his former partner. 

Rust: “You’re looking at it wrong, the sky thing.”

Marty: “How’s that?”

Rust: “Well, once there was only dark. You ask me, the light’s winning.”

I’ve been siting with that conversation and thinking about the cost that comes to those who engage with that battle to keep darkness at bay. In the fictional show, Rust nearly loses his life while bringing to justice a serial murderer. The cost is high.

Real Life Costs

I just finished reading Ayaan Hirsi Ali’s 2007 autobiographical novel Infidel, in which she chronicles leaving Somalia and fighting for the rights of Muslim women in Holland. It’s intense and eye opening. Ayaan talks about the brutal murder of her friend, the Dutch filmmaker Theo Van Gogh, due to his association with her (for collaborating on a film about Muslim women’s rights). Ayaan was in fear of her life and was forced into hiding. The cost for her to expose some of the deep darknesses she experienced in her culture and community was high. I found this really inspiring, as a reader in a Western country, surrounded by a general sense of apathy about right and wrong, good and evil. These ideas are either rejected as being too dogmatic, in favour of relativism: “who’s to say what’s right and wrong? You do you” “Everything depends” or a kind of hesitancy to address evils for fear of being seen as some sort of “phobe (“That’s just culture, don’t be racist”)

This drawing is also inspired by my pastor, Mari-Shell Scott, because she has shared publicly parts of her story about darknesses she has experienced in her life, and has taken up the responsibility and cost of holding the curtain back for others too.

Some of the elements I want to highlight in this image:

  • The mouths represent the sneering that comes from some places when you get involved in the light. Dennis Prager said something that resonated which is this:

“Those who don't fight evil hate those who do; and those who don't fight real evils make up little evils”

There will always be people who lurk in the dark, and enjoy it there, and who try to obstruct those who have stepped out of the dark. That tension seems perennial.

  • There are monsters hiding behind the stairs and claws ready to grab. This speaks to the ongoing existence of real, genuine evil in the world: and a challenge to those who love the light to not be fearful, and to not ignore the existence of evil. It might require some skin in the game, some toughness, some courage to challenge it rather than shrink away and pretend we don’t see what people in our communities are facing in their darkness. The darknesses might be domestic violence, serious mental health challenges, drug issues, a kind of spiritual and existential emptiness, voids of meaning, relational poverty, loneliness, it goes on…the ‘dark’ is there, whether we face the other way and pretend not to know or we have the courage to look at it squarely as courageous people. This challenge is to do the latter.

  • The room is crumbling, despaired, damaged. The extent of the decay probably isn’t even fully visible until the curtain is pulled back. This room is a metaphor for the consequences of darkness: it shatters us, damages us and those around us.

  • The hot air balloons- a sense of adventure, of momentum waits: not stagnant, not boring: the Light comes with a call to adventure, challenge, goodness.

  • The figure holding back the curtain: reminiscent of Jesus being wounded to the end of his life on the cross. The figure represents anyone who picks up the challenge to stand up, do something, care about justice, fight the darkness.

It also occured to me afterwards that there was a curtain in Jesus’ death story too:

Mark 15: 37-39 (MSG) “But Jesus, with a loud cry, gave his last breath. At that moment the Temple curtain ripped right down the middle. When the Roman captain standing guard in front of him saw that he had quit breathing, he said, "This has to be the Son of God!"

I know there are other things going on in that story of the temple curtain ripping in half, but I like the idea that the curtain tearing takes my drawn idea to the next level: The curtain isn’t just held back, temporarily, it’s destroyed, ripped, finished. That to me speaks of hope. Hope, like the dialogue in True Detective suggests, that despite the territory the darkness claims: light is winning; it has won.

Artmaking as Prayer: Introducing our project w/ Dr. Emma Austin

Hello!

It’s been a little while between cyclones…the year absolutely flying by…

Dropping in to share some great news!

My friend Dr. Emma Austin and I have collaborated on a project we are both really excited about.

Prayer/ faith life and spirituality (particularly from the Pentecostal tradition) is a passion of mine, and art making is inextricably linked to how I express this. I am very grateful to have a friend like Emma who saw and helped craft this project into something that could be understood by a broader audience.

We have just had our paper published. See our article here (though it is behind a paywall for most; please contact either of us to read the full version).

We have also been accepted to present on this paper later in the year in the UK at Regents Theological College for a global Pentecostal conference.

To see our full chat about this project:

Artmaking as prayer: full conversation

Creative Deepening: EFIT Meets Art Therapy Webinar

Hi!

Katie Kjelsaas over at Connections Count is passionate about supporting therapists and offering professional development…and I am jumping on board for the next one.

Katie will be discussing her paradigm (Emotionally Focussed Individual Therapy) and I will be sharing some art therapy interventions that fit beautifully into that process (it will be hands on and experiential)

This is totally for you if you are NOT a creative therapist (Please come along, talk therapists!)

You definitely don’t need art skills! Just the willingness to have a go!

Details:

Monday 21 October 2024

7 - 9 pm AEST

We can’t wait to see you there!


Here’s a little more info:



Mountains and Molehills

‘Mountains and Molehills’ 2024 original. Pencil and pen on paper. 29.7x42cm. Enquire for print queries alanabosgra@gmail.com

I recently jotted a note down in my phone when I was out and about (I usually do that so I can come back later and explore the idea when I have time) and I wrote a brief list of something that bothered me during a social interaction. Here’s the list of the things that I perceived which bothered me:

-Lack of imagination 

-Judgement (lack of or unwillingness to understand)

-Close mindedness

-Falseness

I think few things trigger more frustration and existential sadness in me than encountering these things in others. It is alienating and deflating to be around unwarranted judgement..or comments that are based on untruths…or a severe lack of imagination or willingness to understand another persons viewpoint… all of these are pretty much my idea of a bad time (If I hear comments like “Conservatives are all X” or “Progressives are all X” I immediately sense that no serious reflection or nuance will come out of that person’s mouth… No one is “all” anything and people deserve the dignity of being understood, even if you seek to understand and then ultimately disagree with their view). Anyway, after writing this, I thought about the broader cultural moment and broader attitudes particularly Christians (or not even just us- conservatives, and also at this moment, Jews) are facing. I’ve used the concept of mountains (sometimes perhaps large issues and hills to die on) and molehills (smaller less consequential issues) to have a look at these.

I am particularly struggling over ignorant comments I hear in person and on social media (molehills) that I believe are just false and perpetuate untrue stereotypes; but what do you do when challenging that feels like rocking the boat or being disagreeable? How do you respond when the person who may have said those things doesn’t actually have any awareness of the impact of them? I don’t really have answers to my questions yet. Do you let blatant lies go unchecked? Do you wish the person who said them reflected a little more critically on their point of view? Do you wish they realised their ignorance is hurtful? Do you wish there was even a common ground to be able to have that conversation? Do you wish people in some settings you’re in were not so close minded and hostile towards your faith? Do you actually say something? Do you overlook it and recognise their ignorance might also come from their personal experience and maybe even a place of pain? Do you pray for that person, and remember they are allowed the dignity to be wrong? Do you defend what you believe to be true at the cost of social niceties? Or let it slide silently and let it eat you up..? Is it just a little molehill, or does the series of molehills ignored accumulate over time to feel like a mountain? Unfortunately, I have observed that typically, conservative or faith based people tend be less forthright and clear in addressing these tensions and perhaps it is to our own detriment…

What Is Required To Distinguish Between What Is A Mountain And What Is A Molehill? 

  • Discernment. We don’t need to be reactionary to every single comment or attitude in our culture that opposes goodness, truth and beauty (because let’s face it, whatever ideology opposes God also opposes these things too). 

  • We can dislike and disagree fundamentally with the molehills, but we don’t need to lose sleep over them. For example, I am thinking right now of some of the performances in the Paris Olympic opening ceremony that without question were explicit in promoting a fluid and boundary-less sexual ethic..Pagan ancient Greece, anyone? Actually super on brand for the origins of the Olympics. Not only that, but it was also a fairly explicit inversion and mockery of Christian imagery. I find that distasteful, disappointing, unnecessary, predictable, dull, and not beautiful, but it doesn’t need to be the hill I die on. It’s just the natural consequence of valuing ‘inclusion’ (how you very narrowly choose to define that) over the value of beauty (good art is beautiful), truth and goodness. I already know what I value, and the cultural attitudes being promoted in stuff like that doesn’t change what I already know I stand on and why.

  • Some molehills can be left alone. We just don’t need to be keyboard warriors trying to stomp on every single molehill we come across. If we waste effort kicking over every molehill we see, we become like distracted idiots and are not energised for the proper task before us. We aren’t called to angrily kick over molehills without wisdom. We also just don’t have the time realistically to make every molehill into a mountain.

  • My drawing presupposes the existence of actual mountains. They are there, regardless of cultural gaslighting that suggests there are no mountains, that it’s a flat perfect landscape, ‘you do you’, there is no good or evil, it’s relative…that gentle lull into apathy. That is just not true. There are serious issues to address and hills to climb. Evil is evil because it hurts people, and people matter and have value. There is a uniquely Judeo-Christian philosophical basis for why we believe in the existence of good and evil and why we therefore recognise the mountains (evils worth standing against).

  • Mountain climbers have a unique vantage point in that they have perspective. They can factor multiple ideas into their point of view before making sweeping judgements (not to say judgement as a concept is all bad, it’s not; but making right judgement based on a full picture of the landscape is the aim, not just judgment born of prejudice and ignorance).

I’d love to start some reflection and dialogue on this:

  • what are the mountains people of faith face today, in 2024?

  • What are the molehills? How do you tell the difference? How do you respond to both of these?

  • How do you know what to leave and what to face, address, treat as a mountain? 

  • What strengthens you to face the journey you’ve been called to?

  • What fills you with confidence and hope in the face of maybe many, many mountains?

  • If you have advice for me I am all ears…

    My current thought is to approach the situations that bother me with exactly the opposite of the qualities that bother me eg: remaining curious about someone’s dogmatic point of view… being imaginative about how they came to their ideas… suspending judgement of the person even if I judge an idea (distinguishing between people and ideas) avoiding sweeping stereotypes at all times.. seeking to get to the heart of issues instead of taking offence at what I can see on the surface… continuing to pursue goodness and truth..

    Lani x